← Back to Library

Episode #238 ... frankenstein - mary shelley

One of literature's most enduring horror stories was written by an teenager, and it asks questions we're still trying to answer today. Mary Shelley published Frankenstein in 1818 when she was just 20 years old — yet the novel grapples with themes that remain urgently relevant: What happens when scientific progress outpaces ethical responsibility? And at what cost do we pursue mastery over nature?

Clearing Up Misconceptions

Before diving in, three quick clarifications will reshape how you read this story. First, Victor Frankenstein is the scientist who creates the monster; the creature itself has no name — and that's deliberate. Second, the iconic green zombie with bolts through his neck? That's Hollywood's invention from a 1930s film, not Shelley's vision. Her creature is articulate, intelligent, even physically agile — able to climb the Alps and hold conversations. Third, Shelley wrote this at eighteen years old during a volcanic eruption in Indonesia that kept people indoors with nothing but time on their hands.

Episode #238 ... frankenstein - mary shelley

A Remarkable Background

Mary Shelley's origins make this achievement even more striking. She was born Mary Wollstonecraft — daughter of the legendary philosopher who wrote A Vindication of the Rights of Woman. Wollstonecraft died just eleven days after giving birth to her daughter. Growing up without a mother but surrounded by her father's literary circles, young Mary spent her youth immersed in the work of both her parents.

Mount Tambora erupted in 1815 when she was eighteen. With the volcanic ash blocking the sky and communities stuck indoors, Shelley and her friends made a game of writing the scariest story they could. The result: the first draft of Frankenstein — widely considered not only the first science fiction novel ever written but also one of philosophy's greatest works.

She revised the book in 1831 when she was thirty-four, softening some details that had originally caused backlash among readers.

The Story Begins

The narrative opens at the Arctic ice, near the North Pole. Explorer Robert Walton and his crew trap their ship in frozen waters while a massive figure approaches on a dog sled — something neither man nor beast. They discover Victor Frankenstein dying on the ice, nearly lifeless. After warming him, they ask what happened. He begins to tell them his story, hoping it might save them from repeating his mistakes.

Victor describes his childhood in Geneva among loving family, including a girl named Elizabeth whom he eventually loves — originally his cousin in the 1818 version, later changed to an adopted daughter after readers objected. As he matures, Victor becomes obsessed with natural philosophy and the occult, devouring everything about both before his seventeenth birthday arrives. Then scarlet fever takes his mother at the most formative moment of his life.

He decides to travel to Bavaria for formal scientific study.

The Discovery

At university, Victor combines his passion for mystery with a teacher's inspiration in chemistry — specifically toward finding what life really is. After years of research, he believes he's finally discovered what he calls "the principle of life." He could create an entirely new species if this works.

He collects body parts from graveyards and slaughterhouses in secret, assembling the creature piece by piece. The day arrives to test his theory — and Shelley deliberately keeps the actual method vague. What matters is that when the creature opens its eyes, Victor feels no triumph or joy. Only horror and disgust.

He runs from his laboratory apartment, collapses on his bed fully clothed, and sleeps in exhaustion. He dreams of Elizabeth transforming into his dead mother. The creature stands at his bed's foot, reaching toward him. Victor sprints outside and paces all night in the courtyard until morning.

His friend arrives to find the creature gone. Victor tries to forget everything ever happened.

Two Competing Worldviews

This is where Shelley's deeper philosophy emerges. She lived during a cultural shift between two dominant attitudes that become dangerous when combined in one person.

Romantics of her era felt wonder at nature, overwhelmed by its mystery and power — they'd hike mountains and weep at beauty. Enlightenment thinkers like Victor believed nature could be mastered through rational faculties if you simply followed the scientific method. Neither attitude is inherently wrong; both carry value. But Victor's combination of wonder about nature with the drive to control it — while sequestered from community, colleagues, and ethics — produces devastation.

The creature murders innocent people across the countryside.

Science without community checks and ethical consideration creates monsters in the real world.

Shelley titled the book "Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus" — referencing the Greek Titan who stole fire from Zeus, gave it to humans, and was chained for eternity as punishment. Victor wants access to creation itself, and like Prometheus, he'll pay a price for doing so in isolation.

Technology Carries Morality

The galvanic experiments of Shelley's era — running electricity through executed criminals' bodies until their faces convulsed as if alive — were state-of-the-art science. Her point extends beyond any single technology: cutting-edge innovations always require ethical consideration about how they'll impact the community they're released into.

Modern debates over nuclear power, facial recognition, and artificial intelligence confirm she was right. Technology isn't neutral. It carries embedded consequences that must be weighed before release.

Bottom Line

Shelley's core argument remains powerful across two centuries: scientific progress without community ethics produces monsters more dangerous than any creature Victor Frankenstein created. Her biggest vulnerability is that the book doesn't offer solutions — only warnings. But that's precisely why it endures. We still haven't found those checks and balances she warned us about.

Deep Dives

Explore these related deep dives:

Sources

Episode #238 ... frankenstein - mary shelley

by Stephen West · · Watch video

Hello everyone. I'm Steven West. This is philosophize this. patreon.com/filosifies this.

Philosophical writing on Substack at Philosophies this on there. I hope you love the show today. So, this episode's about the philosophical themes of the book Frankenstein by Mary Shel. And I think out of respect to your time, it's worth it to clear up a few misconceptions real briefly right here at the start that'll help frame this whole thing.

First of all, for anyone just getting started with this book, Victor Frankenstein's the name of the scientist that makes the monster in this book. The monster is not named Frankenstein. In fact, the monster in the book doesn't really have a name, which as we'll see is part of the point that Mary Shelley was going for. Secondly, I think most people when they think of Frankenstein's monster, they think of this, giant green dude, bolts coming out of his neck.

He's got a bull cut and he just sort of lumbers around all stiff moaning at people like, like he's a zombie or something. Just know this is a Hollywood thing that came from when they made the Frankenstein movie in the 1930s. This is nothing like the creature Mary Shelley describes in the book. In the book, this creature is articulate.

He's fast, murdering people, planting evidence, framing people for murder. the thing climbs up into the Alps at one point and surprises Victor Frankenstein just sitting on a glacier cuz he wants to have a private conversation with them. Just know that as we talk about this book, this is the actual kind of monster depicted in the story. Hollywood images aside, the last thing I wanted to clear up here is if you wanted to feel horrible about how little you've done with your life, fun fact, Mary Shelley wrote this book when she was 18, 19 years old.

It was published anonymously at first in the year 1818 when she was just 20. A book, by the way, or parts of it were 100 years ead of its time in terms of the philosophy and it being popular to be discussed. A situation that's pretty unbelievable on its own. And it only becomes slightly more believable when you consider the fact that she was the daughter of Mary Woolstonecraft.

Legendary philosopher. We've done an episode on her. Wrote a vindication of the ...